Review: This Is Not a Sex Dungeon

greer-barnes-not-a-sex-dungeon

On February 27th, Temple Horses hosted their This is Not a Sex Dungeon comedy show at Stairs Bar in New York City, including some comedians that you’d recognize from our many comedy sketches. But, we won’t waste your time with our own words since it’d obviously be subjective and masturbation, really. And we don’t do that in public. Sometimes.

That said, read a glowing review below by Amy Hawthorne over at Comedy Groupie. Thanks for letting us just put our hands behind our head and close our eyes, Amy!

Ryan Hoffman and Nick Ruggia, collectively known as the Temple Horses sketch crew, were putting on a live show at Stairs bar that featured a lot of the folks they work with regularly on sketches, who are coincidentally very talented stand-ups who I am very fond of. Andy Sandford has been one of my favorites for years, I think my love for Krystyna is well known by now, and I had the chance to see a number of great folks I don’t see often (or never had before) – Matt Lipton, Alison Klemp, Samantha Bednarz, Nick and Ryan. It was a fantastic show in a nice little downstairs room that was packed with folks ready to have a good time.

But all that pales next to watching Greer Barnes go up. “You’re gonna write about that, right????” Krystyna asked me as we hopped a cab afterward. And I’m still struggling a little with how to do that. See, I spend an inordinate amount of time with Greer, I know the inner workings of his brain and I’ve been goading him for weeks to start taking more risks on stage, to stop feeling like he has to always bat 1.000 (which he does every night at the Cellar) and trust that he can carry a set through untested material just fine. So, when he took the opportunity of the small room with an on board crowd to do just that, my experience of the set was colored by all that knowledge and the fact that he’d done something similar on my show Tuesday at New York Comedy Club.

But I’ll try to tell you what happened from the more objective view of the crowd and the other comedians. Greer came up firing on all cylinders with his typical confidence and charm that immediately puts the audience at ease. He started out just riffing, led into a couple of regular jokes he has, and then the set just… opened up. He tried out new stuff that was everywhere from “I just thought of this” to half baked to almost done. He’d pause periodically and break the fourth wall with meta comments about what he was doing, advice to the comedians in the room, and a treatise on why a wireless mic is for singers, not comedians. He even put the mic down at one point and performed a capella, punctuating it with the note, “You gotta be able to project, even when you don’t have a mic.”

And he made all of it work. Even the commentary had laugh lines dropped in at strategic intervals and the crowd was with him, whether they were laughing at him suddenly switching to his french guy or white girl accent to make a serious point, or listening in rapt attention as he turned to face the side of the stage to illustrate what he was saying about performance. And for the folks in the room that only knew him as Greer from the sketches or Greer from the Cellar or who didn’t even know him, there was that tension of “How much of this is real and how much is performance? Is this guy about to have a breakdown?” that reminded me a lot of watching Brody Stevens for the first few times.

The whole thing was fucking beautiful. It felt real and visceral and spontaneous and alive and dangerous and always on the brink of going off the rails, the way you want your comedy to be in a dark basement in the East Village.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>